I periodically check CNN.com and Time.com for information updates on a variety of fields. Recently, I came across this article that examined what is BEHIND the research surrounding the link between cell phones and cancer/brain tumors. Author Bryan Walsh put a lot of energy into researching his article, and therefore, he formed an extremely well supported and solid opinion about recent research.
His claim:
The studies recently conducted that attempt to explain (or at least shine light on) the link between cell phone usage and cancer rates have yielded more conclusive data. However, the results should be taken with a grain of salt. Don't assume that "no links found" means that usage cannot contribute to cancer. Science can no longer keep up with the exploding population of those who DO have cell phones, and its even more difficult to find those who have not ever used one, and have never owned one.
Bottom line: Keep your wits about you. Don't always listen to what science says without critically evaluating the statistics yourself.
His grounds:
Walsh uses competing sets of data. "There were no increased risks of tumours of the central nervous system, providing little evidence for a causal association." one study concludes.
"Case closed, right? That all depends on your perspective. Other researchers and activists were quick to criticize the study, arguing that it was still not broad enough to fully exonerate cell phones."
The 'other researchers and activists' state: "From the way it was set up originally, this deeply flawed study was designed to fail to find an increased risk of brain tumors tied with cellphone use. In order for any study of a relatively rare disease like brain tumors to find a change in risk, millions must be followed for decades."
His warrant:
By providing the two opposing scholarly opinions, Walsh shows the reader that the first sentence seemed true until the second argument was read and challenged the first. He is demonstrating that listening and believing the first thing we hear could undermine our own health. He is using dramatic foreshadowing to hint to the reader that "if you always take anyone's word, you could give yourself brain cancer". It is an extremely far-fetched correlation, but his evidence allows him to do so. The author implies that if we as readers agree with all the scientific data that comes our way, we will be the cause of our own demise. His qualifiers are words like "may" and "usually" to describe (and absolutely infer) what is sure to happen to readers if they agree with every appeal.
Its definitely helped in my favor as the reader to be able to apply the Toulmin model to my every day reading. I cherish the ease of access I have to the internet and unlimited amounts of news, and I don't want to dive into every website blindly.
Walsh's argument didn't go unnoticed, and the dissection helped me to see what he was truly trying to say. What has Toulmin told you?
Very nicely done. Your separation of data made the post very easy to read. An example of his use of qualifiers would have been well received.
ReplyDeleteGreat read
I really liked how you organized your post by creating separate paragraphs and using italicized and bolded words when you were making a point. It made it very easy to read and helped support your analysis. Great post!
ReplyDeleteI liked how you separated each paragraph and highlighted certain words in italics. It made your post very easy to read, and it also helped support your opinion and analysis. I think you did a great job.
ReplyDeleteThe organization of this post was very helpful. You made each of you ideas very clear and easy to read. Overall good work.
ReplyDelete